Monday, 21 March 2011

Consulting Certitude

I'm often put in the uncomfortable position of having to provide answers to my clients, on vexing problems that they have; the only reason they called my company in the first place-they expect us to provide expert answers, based on our experience and past work with several clients. You may wonder why I call this uncomfortable, for expertise and knowledge is what we are supposed to bring to the table.


The culture of certain knowledge
There is no fundamental issue with clients seeking ‘knowing counsel’. But what I have issue with is how they can expect certitude, especially when it is often the same certitude that got them into trouble in the first place! Let me illustrate with a few typical examples, which pretty much capture what we encounter in almost every other engagement.

About 18 months ago, we did work for a mid-sized family run business based in New Delhi, who having raised money from the capital markets, embarked on a retail project. A year down down their journey, while they did get their venture of the ground, customer reaction to the concept was slack,-resulting in lower than planned revenues, costs higher than planned and what’s more, they had burnt most of their funding and were staring down the investors' barrel. We were called in when panic set in.

After the first 2 rounds of meetings, when they were convinced about our credentials, they asked us to “give us the answers”. We decided to visit their locations and come up with an approach. Having done the recce, we developed our thoughts on what seemed wrong and said, “We have a hypothesis, but don’t have a position on the subject yet; it needs some research and investigation”. Right then, we almost lost the assignment! The client retorted: “That’s not why I called you; you guys were supposed to be the experts!”

Saner counsel soon prevailed, he relented and engaged us, to identify the flaws and implement the corrections. But as we dived in to discover and questioned several not-so-far-ago decisions, what seemed to have gone wrong in the first, place were the following:
  • Little of no thought over the brand name- one was picked based on the recommendation of a reasonably big and reputed advertising agency.
  • Brand identity/design were developed by a well reputed global design firm, but out of sync with the geographical-markets/ audience profile they were addressing.
  • No “customer-check” on store-merchandise-concepts, least of all about locations, which also were recommended and hunted out again by “reputed real estate consultants”.
  • An HR / recruitment and organization cost strategy that seemed completely out of whack with the business needs, and yet recommended by another big HR firm.
Eventually, as we engaged collaboratively with the client and his board, the Managing Director became reflective on what went right and wrong. Prima-facie, they had selected the right market framework (forward integration), adequate and right form of money (equity, not debt), engaged the right partners to help them with the tasks on hand. Although the client was loathe admitting it in the beginning, the first underpinnings of trouble were that the client was looking for certitude right through and the “experts” gave it to him, double quick and at considerable billing rates. Even during the course of the engagement, when we came up with alternative ways of cracking the problem and suggested some “investigation/research” he would lapse into his old certitude seeking behaviour.

After much agonizing and seeking several checks with consumers and investing adequate time in discovering what we hoped were the right answers, our recommendations were delivered. I think the client now believes he has found a way out, rather than is certain about the way forward. Of course, how the client eventually recovers is a function of implementation, which is now underway. But long after the mandate is over, I sometimes agonize over how close to or far away from getting it right we were.

6 months earlier, two weeks into the engagement with a large MNC entertainment client, in one of the first review meetings when I said “I don’t know, but able and willing to find out”, the looks I got from Senior Managers was “how did this guy get to be consultant?” Last week, I was called in by another acquaintance turned client prospect, which was in similar trouble and during the first 2 meetings; again I encountered the “Can you give us your recommendation in 2 weeks” tone. Fortunately past acquaintance helped in turning the debate around to “Let’s find out as soon as possible”.

On other projects where we have to collaborate with other companies such as design and advertising agencies, I often find such “knowing” certitude about their recommendations, and downright disdain for inquiry.

The temptation is grave; I've had co-consultant colleagues of mine, who would pip in to my ear every now and then and say “Give him what he is looking for; we cannot be more loyal than the king”.  But, I resist. Maybe because I cannot begin to believe that I am “the expert”, even if my colleagues and clients were willing charitably, to confer that title on me. Maybe I can’t take myself as seriously; maybe my early ‘Advaita’ upbringing came in the way. I am still discovering which.


Can one learn elsewhere?
Different industries/ markets, different people, different organization structures, different times and yet, déjà vu! This got me thinking about why business seeks such certitude and wonder if it is hard-wired into some human behaviour to seek so. Or is it some genetic marker which pre-disposes some people to behave so and others to behave differently? Or is it the lowering of the age at the C-level which is causing this lately?

When I look around in other areas of seeking answers, such as in the sciences, the thing that comes to mind immediately is “my reading” of the main theme running behind “Contact”, the classic Carl Sagan book-turned-movie, so movingly acted in, by Jodie Foster. Amateur critics may confuse it to represent human reaction to dealing with the alien/ unknown, and the imponderables thereabout, but my take is never mind which side of scepticism you fall, it’s the process of discovery, constantly.

Now think politics. What caused the Bush presidency to go the way it went? Or why Advani and his ilk have bitten the dust recently. Isn't there a fixed, knowing certainty about the way they think? Almost driven by divine prescription, you might say.

And yet, when I heard Billy Maher say "Yeah you could be right. I don't think it's very likely. But yes, you could be right. Because my big thing is, I don't know. That's what I preach. I preach the Gospel of 'I Don't Know.' That's what I'm here promoting: Doubt. That's my product. The other guys are selling Certainty. Not me, I'm on the corner with Doubt." (Bill Maher from "Religulous"); it tells me that religion too is looking for those answers.

I think business could learn something from a range of schools of inquiry and thought. So I propose to set about doing some academic research in the coming weeks to determine if there is anything to discover in this area, which business could benefit from.

Any co-conspirators out there?

No comments: