Sunday, 9 January 2011

Never Really or Not Returning Indian - Not again !!!

Must do my bit to publicise the other point of view...and so wrote this piece to the editor...in response to an article available at this link:

http://www.thehindu.com/todays-paper/tp-features/tp-openpage/article1074269.ece

In a week when the Pravasi Bharatiya Divas was being celebrated, I read with a sense of déjà-vu the above article. What I heard the gentleman say was a typical opinion from an NRI, several of whom we are so happy to see emigrate from this wretched land. For somebody who left India 20 years ago to whine about what her society and civic administration hasn’t achieved, to the aid of which this gentleman contributed precious little, is indeed a bit much.

This is not unique to NRIs (Never Really Indians?). Increasingly we find criticism of this sort in our media and public discourse coming from well-heeled urban cynics, who having benefitted from government subsidised engineering (IIT) & management (IIM) education, now rather speciously, go about criticising our government & civil society for doing little. We’d much rather they’d paid their taxes on time and voted to make a change, than shoot their mouth off on TV debates and op-ed pages.

Must point out that I haven’t voted once either, busy as I have been with my own life and career, but the least I can say for myself is that I don’t pontificate about what society & government hasn't done for me. In fact, for somebody who came from a “sarkari” family, growing up in the 60s, 70’s & 80’s, I am thankful that my country gave me the 17 years of top-class education, for a cumulative fee that I now pay every year for my 13 year old’s private schooling! This is the economy & country that that now allows us these fancy airports, air-conditioned Volvo busses and clean toilets in Railway stations; for which people of my parents’ generation toiled, travelling to work in dirty DTC and Pallavan busses, on “3rd class” Indian Railways sleepers, to create opportunities that Nehru & Shastri visioned collectively for us. We’d find our own cures to our ailments, Mr. Minhas, thank you very much for your solicitous advice.

I hold no grudge against émigrés, coming as I do from a family full of folks who emigrated to various parts of the world. I am myself an internal émigré, whose parents hail from Tamilnadu, went to Delhi as a 3 month old; have lived in Delhi, Jammu, Madras, Lucknow, Hyderabad, Bombay and now in Bangalore. But every town & province that I have lived in in this country that Mr. Minhas finds dirty & so criticises, has added value to me; in turn hope that I have contributed to those places in the form of taxes and tolls none of which Mr. Minhas pays in any meaningful measure.

1 comment:

Srinivasan "GS" Gowrikanthan said...

Good one!!!! These guys who literally "raw away" without having the strength to battle it out need to be more circumspect in their opinions!

And in a roundabout way, some of those who left, and wanted to make a difference have made and are still making a huge difference - Take Sam Pitroda for one!